Slam and sleaze is Diana's expertise
By MICHAEL JENKINSON -- Edmonton Sun
As a long-time fan of professional wrestling, I approached the new
book on Calgary's Hart family, Under the Mat: Inside Wrestling's Greatest
Family, with some trepidation.
After all, it's written by Diana Hart, the ex-wife of British Bulldog Davey
Boy Smith and the youngest living child of Stu and Helen Hart. The advance
buzz on the book from people in the wrestling business was that it would only
deepen the well-publicized rifts in the family.
To that end, Under the Mat doesn't disappoint. But because of that, the
book is a huge disappointment if you're looking for any kind of redeeming
social value in what is essentially a gossip and scandal book - and a legal
minefield. I can't imagine that Under the Mat is going to do anything but
drive the Hart family even further apart - and that is so terribly sad.
THE BOOK GRABS YOU RIGHT AWAY
That said, the book grabs you from the opening paragraph and doesn't let
you go. I read all but the final 25 pages in one four-hour sitting and was
left stunned by its contents. After I finished it, I was left thinking that I
hope Diana Hart has a good lawyer. She's going to need it.
Her late brother Owen's widow, Martha, who won a huge settlement from the
WWF stemming from Owen's death, serves as one particularly huge target for
Diana.
Only Owen, WWF head Vince McMahon, and to some degree, her father, Stu, are
spared her barbs. Everyone else in the family gets their reputations shredded.
Even if you can somehow rationalize the need for Diana to expose the sundry
sins of her own family, she occasionally name-drops other non-family wrestlers
and starts talking about the terrible things they did on the road.
She very casually brings up one former WWF wrestler by name and states
baldly that he was portrayed as a real family guy on WWF television but had
girlfriends on the road.
And to what purpose? The guy gets mentioned just that one time in the book,
and then never again, and the only lasting imprint he apparently left on Diana
is that he had flings on the road. So she decides to share that little bit of
gossip with the world.
OWEN'S DEATH RIPPED THE FAMILY APART
But that's the question that can be asked about this entire book: to what
purpose? Why was it written?
Owen's death ripped the family apart. Any illusions long-time Stampede
Wrestling fans may have had about the Hart family and their legendary Sunday
dinners at the Hart mansion were shattered in the aftermath of Owen's 27-metre
plunge from the roof of a Kansas City arena to his death during a WWF
pay-per-view event in 1999.
The bitter lawsuit Martha launched against the WWF further divided the
family into essentially pro- and anti-Vince McMahon camps, with the parents,
Stu and Helen caught in the middle.
Diana's disgust with big brother Bret and widow Martha is obvious in the
book - but it wasn't exactly a big secret before either. Which again begs the
question, why did she feel it necessary to share her family's closet full of
skeletons with the world?
The tragedy of her sharing her family's turmoil with the world is only
compounded by the fact that Hart takes little if any time in the book to
actually step back and look at the big picture.
The closest she comes to any kind of realization of how disturbing are the
stories she's telling is when she talks about her brother Dean, who died of
kidney failure. She writes that Dean must have wondered why, with so many
siblings, no one donated a kidney to him. Diana admits that everyone was so
wrapped up in their lives, they didn't realize how grave was his condition.
But that's not even the saddest part of the book. That dubious honour is
for the penultimate paragraph, where Diana talks about how her two children
are already planning careers in the WWF.
If nothing else is made obvious by Under the Mat, it is that professional
wrestling didn't make the Hart family. It destroyed them.
That another generation of Alberta's most dysfunctional family wants to
take up the profession that has brought the Harts as much pain as it has
success, suggests there are more troubled times ahead for the Harts.
Michael Jenkinson can be reached by e-mail at mj@the-newsroom.com.
His homepage is at http://www.the-newsroom.com.
Letters to the editor should be sent to letters@edm.sunpub.com.
Related stories
Nov. 5: Explosive tell-all book brings on family feud
Nov. 4: Diana Hart chat transcript
Oct. 26: Diana Hart book will shock
Oct. 4: Mother's health, book on Diana Hart-Smith's mind
June 5: Diana Hart book out this fall